One of my most favorite books has been made into a movie...Then She Found Me by Elinor Lipman
tells the tale of a high school teacher, April, who was adopted, but is "found" by her birth mother Bernice when she is in her 30's and having recently lost her parents. It turns out her birth mother had been following her life, and once she learned that April's parents were gone, decided to re-enter her world. April's birth mother is a morning talk show host and is everything studious, Latin-teacher, April isn't: loud, showy and very loose with the truth.
When I learned about the movie - the casting seemed wonderful. Helen Hunt as April and Bette Midler as Bernice would make a great pair to bring this story to life.
My first case of movie bummer-itis hit when I learned that the film isn't playing in my town - it's not even playing in my STATE! For the largest state in the US, Alaska can seem very small....
My second case of "movie bummer-itis" struck when I watch the trailer on Fandango.
What?! April is married???
What?! She teaches elementary school?
What?! She's dying to have a baby?
What?! Colin Firth's not Dwight?
What?! She falls in love with a man with children?
What?! What?! What?! What happened to the story I loved????
Here's the back of the edition of the book I own:

The movie has kept the mother-daughter relationship somewhat the same, but......April's not the same character....
The author,
Elinor Lipman,
wrote on Amazon.com about the changes in the story:
"
People ask all the time if I mind the changes from book to screenplay, and are surprised when I say no. It's hard to explain why I'm not feeling sentimental or possessive, but it's part relief (it was optioned 18 years ago) and very much the quality of the screenplay. (I laughed, I cried.)"
She also wrote a response to blog entries just like mine here: My Book - The Movie, or I seem to be in a tiny minority of authors who love their adaptation.
Ah, Elinor, but I care...this novel is one that I have reread numerous times. I looked for any other blogs who might also be disappointed in the changes from the novel to the screen play, but found none. Am I the only one????
I'm not as bummed anymore that it's not playing on the big screen here in our town. I'll definitely see it on DVD or iTunes rental, but I don't feel the same excitement after watching the trailer. Elinor's review on her website is positive and encouraging, though:
"I saw
TSFM on Oct. 16 at a screening, and adored it. I laughed and I cried and I came away calling Helen Hunt (who wrote the screenplay and directed the film) a genius. Bette Midler as Bernice--you can't take your eyes off her. Fabulous performances all around. "
More of Elinor's books have been optioned for movies: Books into Movies. I've read all the books and love each in it's own way....maybe the next screen writers won't change so much?
Either way, I still have the books.....the books are always better than the movies, anyway, aren't they???
PS - the snow is gone and the temps are rising....I think summer is finally on it's way!